How to Choose an Expat Tax Accountant: 10 Questions to Ask
By Heavnn Editorial TeamReviewed by Stéphane Gombauld, co-founderLast reviewed 19 November 2026
Quick answer
Choose an expat tax accountant who can show authorisation to represent you before the tax authority, experience with both countries you deal with, a written scope listing every form, and a habit of planning before filing. Ask the ten questions below in writing and compare answers, not just prices.
The 10 questions to ask
- Can you represent me before the tax authority? In the US, Enrolled Agents, CPAs and attorneys have unlimited representation rights; other preparers have limited rights. Other countries have their own registers.
- Which countries do you cover? Both ends of your situation, or only one?
- How many clients like me do you have? Remote employee, freelancer, founder, retiree: each has different forms.
- What exactly is included? Ask for the list of forms and returns, including FBAR, Form 8938 and foreign-company forms where relevant.
- Will you compare FEIE and the foreign tax credit? Or file whatever you did last year?
- How do you handle past years? If you are behind, do they handle catch-up procedures such as the IRS Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures?
- Who prepares my foreign return? If it is another firm, who coordinates?
- What is the fee and what triggers extra charges? New forms, amendments, notices.
- How do you communicate and how fast? Time zones matter abroad.
- What do you need from me, and when? A good firm sends a checklist and a calendar.
Red flags
- Promises of "zero tax" without asking where you live and why.
- No written engagement letter.
- Fees based on your refund.
- Advice to skip FBAR because "nobody checks".
- No questions about your residency in the other country.
Types of providers compared
| Provider | Strengths | Limits |
|---|
| Large international firm | Complex structures, multiple countries | Cost, slower for individuals |
| Specialist expat firm | Volume, standardised processes | May cover only the US side |
| Local accountant abroad | Knows your new country | Often unfamiliar with US forms |
| Software | Cheap for simple cases | No judgement on residency or structure |
| Coordinated platform such as Heavnn | Both sides of the move, plan plus filings | Best for location-independent profiles rather than large estates |
CPA, Enrolled Agent or tax preparer?
| Credential | What it means | Representation before the IRS |
|---|
| CPA (Certified Public Accountant) | State-licensed accountant; tax is one of several specialities | Unlimited |
| Enrolled Agent (EA) | Licensed by the IRS itself, tested specifically on tax | Unlimited |
| Tax attorney | Lawyer; useful for disputes, criminal exposure, complex structures | Unlimited |
| Other paid preparer (PTIN holder) | Registered with the IRS, no exam required | Limited to returns they prepared, if in the Annual Filing Season Program |
For expat returns, an Enrolled Agent who specialises in Americans abroad is often as good a choice as a CPA. What matters most is how many expat returns the person files each year and whether they understand your other country.
How to check a firm before you sign
- Verify the credential: the IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers lists CPAs, EAs and attorneys with an IRS registration.
- Read the engagement letter: scope, forms, deadlines, what happens with an IRS notice.
- Ask for a sample timeline: when they need your documents, when you review, when they file.
- Ask who does the work: the senior person you spoke to, or a junior team?
- Test their answer to one real question: for example "should I use the exclusion or the credit this year, and why?"
A simple decision guide
- Salary abroad, nothing else: good software or a hybrid platform is often enough.
- Self-employed or a spouse who is not American: use a specialist expat preparer.
- Own a foreign company, hold foreign funds, or have years to catch up: specialist CPA or EA firm, ideally with planning experience.
- Moving again soon, or income in several countries: an international tax advisor who coordinates both ends.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an expat tax accountant and an international tax advisor?
An expat tax accountant mainly prepares and files your returns; an international tax advisor plans residency and structure. Many expats need both, at different moments.
Should my expat tax accountant be a CPA?
Not necessarily. Enrolled Agents specialise in tax and can represent you before the IRS. What matters most is experience with expat returns and with your other country.
When should I hire one?
Before your first year abroad ends, ideally before you move, so that the first return reflects a deliberate FEIE-or-credit choice.
What are red flags when hiring a tax accountant?
No written engagement letter, fees tied to the size of your refund, promises of zero tax before asking about your situation, advice to skip FBAR, and refusing to sign the return as the paid preparer.
Is it better to use a CPA or a tax preparer?
For anything beyond a simple return, choose someone with unlimited representation rights (CPA, Enrolled Agent or attorney) and real expat experience. An unlicensed preparer cannot represent you in most IRS matters.
Keep reading
Sources